EL KIT setup

SFCC members contribute to national electrofishing data analysis project

29 May 2015

Today Marine Scotland Science published their initial findings on the analysis of salmon fry data, provided by SFCC members, SEPA, MSS and others.

The full report is available here: http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2015/05/2163/downloads

SFCC wish to thank its members again for the supply of data under short timescales. In a letter to the Trusts, MSS thanked them for their support and requested further assistance to quality control the information prior to further analysis.

This work indicates a potential approach for practical managers to interpret their electrofishing data results. Although the results are only preliminary, this project aims to deliver practical assessment tools for fisheries managers in the longer-term, allowing them to quantify the difference between observed fish numbers in a given electrofishing event, and what could be expected based on an average national model produced at the  Scottish scale. In practical terms this could  be used to identify poorly performing sites for further investigation and then potentially to help target restoration work or other management actions. For an example of the application of this approach to selected data from the River Dee catchment, please see page 32. 

This report also provides new insights into the practice of electrofishing in Scotland, and specifically some of the factors affecting capture efficiency (including Fisheries Trust, day of the year, year, region and others). While the practice of multi-pass electrofishing has declined in recent years in favour of semi quantitative methods, this report calls for all organisations to maintain an annual programme of multi-pass fishings and cautions against assumptions of constant capture probability. The findings here will be fed in to the SFCC electrofishing training programme at Team Leader and Team Leader Refresher level.

SFCC and its members look forward to continuing to work with MSS on this project, supplying and quality controlling data for further analysis.

SFCC, 29th May 2015


Executive Summary

Models of juvenile salmonid abundance are required to inform electrofishing based assessment approaches and potentially as an intermediate step in scaling conservation limits from data rich to data poor catchments. This report describes an approach for modelling large-scale spatio-temporal variability in fish densities using GIS derived covariates. The technical challenges, modelling approaches and software developed during the project are described. The utility of the approach was illustrated by fitting models to data on Atlantic salmon fry.

Multi-pass electrofishing data was collated from fisheries trusts, fisheries boards, SEPA and Marine Scotland. Covariates describing spatial, temporal and habitat variability were obtained for each sampling event. A two stage likelihood based modelling approach was developed. Firstly, capture probability was modelled in relation to covariates. Secondly, densities were modelled in relation to covariates, conditional on estimated capture probabilities. A software package was developed for the R statistical programming environment to perform the analysis.

The modelling approach was illustrated using a case study of Atlantic salmon fry. Capture probability varied strongly with data provider, time of sampling (Day of Year: DoY), location and year and to a lesser extent with distance to sea, channel width and gradient. The risks of assuming constant capture probability were demonstrated by comparing modelled density estimates with those obtained by assuming a constant mean capture probability. Assumptions of constant capture probability resulted in considerable spatial bias in density estimates, but could also generate temporal bias. This illustrates the continued requirement for multi-pass electrofishing data and the constraints on the use of single-pass or timed data for quantitative assessments in the absence of adequate calibration.

Fry densities varied with catchment, and with habitat variables: distance to sea, altitude, upstream catchment area and to a lesser extent channel width, gradient, DoY and landuse. The potential of spatial covariates (catchment and river connectivity) to indicate deviation from an average national model and thus describe the relative performance of catchments or sites is illustrated as a potential assessment approach for management.

It is recommended that future work focusses on (1) quality control of site location data and identification of non-representative electrofishing samples (e.g.fishing only marginal areas in wide rivers) through interaction with data providers and (2) further development of software to allow simultaneous consideration of multiple species (salmon and trout) and life stages (fry and parr) together with river network effects across multiple catchments.

Home Wild Fisheries Web Map Electrofishing Database Contact Site Search Privacy Statement Terms and Conditions Site Map

© 2021 SFCC. All Rights Reserved.

Scottish Fisheries Co-Ordination Centre (SFCC), Marine Scotland Freshwater Laroratory, Faskally, Pitlochry, Perthshire PH16 5LB

Member Login

We use cookies to help improve this website. Close